Sen. Ron Johnson Calls Social Security a 'Ponzi Scheme,' Says Shut It Down
Sen. Ron Johnson's "Ponzi scheme" remark has set off a firestorm over Social Security's future.
Washington woke up to a political firestorm on Wednesday after Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, the chairman of the Senate Budget Committee, declared on live television that Social Security is a scam that cannot be saved and should simply be shut down. The comments, made on Fox Business just hours before Johnson was due to chair a Senate hearing on the program, instantly became one of the most talked-about moments of the day in American politics.
Johnson did not soften his language. He called the retirement program "grotesque" and a "Ponzi scheme," arguing that workers have been misled for decades about where their payroll taxes actually go. In his telling, the money is spent the moment it arrives, today's retirees are paid with taxes collected from today's workers and borrowed funds, and there is no pot of savings waiting for anyone. His message was blunt: the system cannot be fixed, so it should be closed down and people should hope to recover some of what they paid in.
The timing was no accident. Johnson had released a committee memo titled "Social Security: The Reality ... a Legal Ponzi Scheme" ahead of the hearing, and his memo put the program's shortfall at roughly $511 billion by 2032, the year the retirement trust fund is expected to run dry. But by the afternoon, under sharp questioning from Democrats including Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, Johnson walked his words back. He called the "shut it down" line an imprecise statement and insisted he is not proposing to end Social Security, even as he stood by his warning that the program's finances are in deep trouble.
The Social Security trust funds are projected to run dry within six years unless Congress acts.
Behind the shouting match sits a real and worsening problem that both parties acknowledge. The Social Security trust funds are projected to run out of reserves within about six years, and the Congressional Budget Office has warned that benefits could then fall by roughly 26 percent. Two-thirds of older Americans depend on the program for more than half of their income, and for more than a quarter of seniors it is their entire retirement income. Advocates warn that shutting the program down would push millions of seniors and people with disabilities toward homelessness and hunger.
The two sides offer very different answers. Johnson's memo calls for repealing the automatic benefit cut that would hit when the trust fund runs dry, and then tackling the wider federal debt. Democrats, led by voices like Senator Bernie Sanders, say the fix is to make the wealthy pay their fair share, for example by lifting the cap on earnings subject to payroll tax. Neither side has the votes to force its plan through on its own, and Congress has not yet agreed on any fix at all.
For now, the fight is about the words as much as the math. Johnson's remark gave Democrats a ready-made attack line heading into the new Congress, while his walk-back gives Republicans room to say he was describing a crisis, not proposing an end to the program. What is not in dispute is the clock: with the trust fund's reserves draining year by year, the lawmakers elected in this month's midterms will have to decide whether to raise revenue, cut benefits, or find a compromise before the money runs out.
Source: MarketWatch — https://www.marketwatch.com/story/social-security-should-be-shut-down-this-republican-senator-says-8f7fef81
#USNews #BreakingNews #SocialSecurity #RonJohnson #Politics


Comments
Post a Comment